Terms of office exist in part
to protect officeholders and their respective policies from being immediately
overturned by an electorate acting without the benefit of inside information,
especially in foreign policy. In the space of several years, however, the role
of electoral judgment, including values, beliefs and even ideologies, can
outweigh the fact that voters are not privy to government-only information. The
free press can arguably provide enough information to legitimate popular
sovereignty even with respect for foreign policy. By 2026, reports of Russia’s
unprovoked military invasion of Ukraine for years, and of Israel’s genocidal
intent (and consequences) in Gaza (as determined by the UN) were sufficient that
virtually any American (or European) in denial of either atrocity could be
reckoned as being “off” mentally, at least with respect to allowing one’s ideology
to block facts on the ground. Those facts included arrest warrants issued by
the International Criminal Court for both Putin and Netanyahu. The two wholesale
instances of raw militaristic aggression naturally triggered the innate human
instinctual urge for justice around the world, and yet no “coalitions of the
willing” had been willing to go into Ukraine and Gaza to put an end to the unjustified,
excessive carnage. Even within the U.S., the federal government seemed cut off
from grassroot preferences to aid Ukraine and Gaza rather than enable Russia
and Israel. That the atrocities had been going on for years by 2026 means that
the American electorates had a legitimate say in their federal government’s foreign
policies, including on whether foreign aid should continue to be given to Israel,
regardless of which particular regime happens to be in power there.
In November 2026, while British
Prince Harry was visiting Ukraine for the fourth time since Russia had begun
its invasion, he told a journalist, “I think there’s been a big separation
between what American society feel regarding support for Ukraine, which I think
is incredibly high and always has been, compared to a certain group, or in this
case an administration, that was perhaps thinking about it differently.”[1]
Harry Windsor had returned to Britain months earlier after having lived in
California for six years. Perhaps he could have made the same observation
concerning the gap between the U.S.’s continued funding of Israel (even of weapons!)
and the natural emotional reaction of disgust that many Americans may likely
had from the news stories coming out of Gaza of the inhuman mentality and
aggression by Israeli forces against people conveniently deemed to be subhuman.
Public statements by senior officials of the Israeli government that everyone,
even infants, in Gaza were guilty and so deserved to die for what a few
Palestinians did in 2023 in Israel made it easy to regard the Israeli state
alongside Nazi Germany, and yet even after the “blue wave” landslide in congressional
elections in 2026, two pro-Israel establishment politicians in Congress were
poised to assume its two most powerful offices—Speaker of the House and
Majority Leader of the Senate.
Not even an electorate’s visceral
reactions against two mass atrocities, neither of which could be justified
morally, may be enough to result in a shift in course in a government’s foreign
policy. It is as if the ship of state had a rudder that was too small for the
machinery of state, similar to the case of the ill-fated Titantic in 1912, whose
rudder was too small to turn the ship enough to avoid the iceberg ahead in
time. The gap between the electorate and its government can be likened to the
communication system on a ship not being operational, which, by the way, was
not the case on the Titanic; rather, the ship was simply too big for its
rudder.
Within a given term of office, whether 2, 4, or 6 years, the public interest in giving officeholders some time to enact their policies is worthy of being protected, but when up for reelection, the popular sovereign—the People—can and should be able to effect a change in direction without the remaining status quo in the government being able to exercise a de facto brick wall. Considering how long Russia’s invasion and Israel’s holocaustic genocide had been going on by November, 2026, the will of the People being expressed by majorities then should not had to faced entrenched office-holders not up for reelection then. In other words, a government of the People should not slow down an electorate’s verdict such that the People would have to wait another two years for yet another election that might then be sufficient to amass enough force for change in the halls of government. Essentially, my point is that the machinery of government in a republic should not be so resistant to change as conveyed even in a landslide. So Harry Windsor was correct in being astonished at the ongoing gap weeks after the 2026 congressional election. Perhaps the U.S. system should make more use of binding referendi—questions of policy put to the voters in non-technical language befitting the popular sovereign—so a shift in the electorate can be more immediately put into action by the federal government.
“Should the U.S. continue
to foreign aid, whether as money or weapons, to Israel?” “Should the U.S. aid
Ukraine militarily?” That the second question is admittedly vague befits an
electorate, so a role for Congress and the U.S. administration in filling in the
details would be necessary. For example, in what sense is militarily?
Foreign aid of money and weapons to Ukraine? American troops in Ukraine? American
combat against Russian forces within Ukraine? No answers to these questions
would include doing nothing, or, even worse, enabling Russia by buying its oil.
If not enough members of Congress are up for reelection in a given cycle for an
electoral shift on a policy to be implemented legislatively, especially if there
is not a presidential election, then the use the referendum devise is warranted
if indeed the government is indeed of the People.
1. Danica Kirka, “UK’s
Prince Harry Sees ‘Big Separation’ Between US Administration, Public on Support
for Ukraine,” APnews.com, November 18, 2026.